Car insurance is a huge annual cost for most households, and massive increases have left many drivers finding it more and more difficult to insure their cars.
Drivers with clean licenses, no claims, and no penalty points regularly report hikes in the hundreds, while insurance companies fail to provide reasonable reasons for the increases.
Even the government now considers the issue to be so import that it established the Cost of Car Insurance Working Group to look at ways to get the cost of car insurance under control.
We don’t offer a car insurance comparison for Irish drivers on bonkers.ie yet, but we do know a thing or two about reducing the cost of car insurance.
Every year we challenge the drivers in our office to beat their renewal quotes, we’ve been successful every year, and we’ve learned a few things along the way. We often save hundreds, and our best result was to halve a comprehensive insurance renewal quote with a saving of €655 which you can read about here: “Is it still possible to get cheaper car insurance?”
Despite rising costs, car insurance is still a competitive business with dozens of insurance companies competing for your business. So, the best way to tackle your renewal quote and reduce your costs is to pitch the car insurance companies against each other.
This is our tried and tested method for beating your renewal quote:
Treat your renewal letter as a guide. It is the highest price you will pay for car insurance this year - you can do better!
When you receive your renewal letter, don’t ignore it. Your insurance company only needs to give you 20 working days’ notice of renewal, so get on the phone and get at least three new quotes from different insurers. This will give you a good idea of the range of premium prices available for the same level of car insurance. You should be able to beat the renewal quote because most insurance companies have special deals for new customers.
In our experience, the phone is the best way to get a car insurance quote because agents can use discretionary discounts - especially if you tell them that you have a better price from another insurer.
This step is especially important for owners of older cars, exotics, modified cars, and cars with big engines. Some major insurance companies don’t want to insure cars like these and may offer ridiculous quotes to send you on your way.
Some insurance companies won’t insure a car that’s more than 15 years old (even with a valid NCT), and others have lists of cars and driver types that they don’t want on their books. This is where you’ll need to do some extra calling around to companies that will insure unusual cars, and not-so-perfect drivers. But it’s nearly always worth it… well, unless you’re a 18 year old male with a modified Skyline!
All comprehensive car insurance policies include an excess amount; this is the amount you must pay in the event of an accidental damage claim. You can usually choose how much you want this excess to be and it can make a big difference to the price you pay for car insurance.
Once you’ve armed yourself with a few quotes, call your existing insurer. Tell them you're surprised that the premium is as high as it is (even if you're not). Ask how much it was last year, and if it’s gone up, ask why. This will tell them that you are serious about paying them as little as possible.
You can also tell your insurer the price of your best quote. Your premium is much more flexible than you may think and to keep you as a customer, your insurer will probably reduce your premium. If they do, great, but keep pushing. Ask if this is their best and final rate - you still might squeeze another few euro out of them. This should give you your best renewal rate from your existing insurer.
Make your selection, call your insurer and tell them the good news - you've just given them the business so they should be happy. And you'll be starting cover with a new insurer or renewing with your existing one at a price that’s better than your renewal.
By using this approach, you should certainly save money. All it takes is a few phone calls which you won't have to make again for another year. And to save a couple of hundred euro, it’s not that much trouble really, is it?
There are a range of steps that you may consider if you’re not having much luck beating your renewal. Here’s a few:
If you have been denied car insurance from at least three insurance companies, you can appeal to Insurance Ireland’s Declined Cases Committee. The committee will review you case and will generally be able to get motor insurance for you unless it would be contrary to the public interest. It is worth noting that extremely high quotes can be considered refusals too. More information on the Declined Cases Agreement is available from Insurance Ireland.
We’re Ireland’s leading price comparison and switching site. We’re free to use and make comparing prices across suppliers quick and easy!
We save you time by bringing you all the best deals in one place. Every year we help tens of thousands of customers to switch and save money!
We’re 100% impartial and are also accredited by the Commission for Regulation of Utilities (CRU) as an impartial, accurate and independent supplier of energy price comparisons.