Image Women less aware of dual pricing than men says latest survey
Image Rob Flynn
Staff Writer

Despite calls from some for the practice to be banned, dual pricing is a fairly common feature in Ireland’s insurance market, with some more susceptible to the practice than others, according to the latest survey findings.

In July we reported on the Central Bank wrapping up its investigation into dual pricing in Ireland’s car and home insurance market, particularly the practice of price walking.

The CBI’s third and final report announced its intentions to ban the price walking but it stopped short of banning dual pricing.

This comes as new research shows that more than half of people have experienced dual pricing in the Irish insurance market, with women less aware of it than men.

The survey, commissioned by the insurance provider Peopl.ie, also shed some light into just how susceptible consumers potentially are to being taken advantage of by pricing practices.

However, before we get into the findings, here’s a reminder of the difference between dual pricing and price walking.

Dual pricing and price walking

The practice of dual pricing occurs when an insurer charges loyal customers a higher premium than new customers, despite having similar risk profiles.

Price walking on the other hand is a form of dual pricing and is where loyal customers end up getting charged more each year upon renewal. This is often referred to as a loyalty premium.

Survey findings

A total of 6 in 10 people (58%) in Ireland have experienced the practice of dual pricing across a number of insurance products in the Irish market.

This is according to the latest nationwide survey of 1,000 people commissioned by Peopl.ie, a provider of home, travel and life insurance.

However, a further 24% of respondents claimed they didn’t know what dual pricing was, and according to Peopl Insurance, could very well mean they have “unknowingly fallen foul of it” before without being aware.

Discussing the results of the survey, Paul Walsh, CEO of Peopl Insurance said:

“Our survey really shines a light on just how many people are affected by dual pricing – a practice which, at the very least, is a questionable way of pricing insurance. Insurance is a product that is needed in pretty much every household throughout the country, so the way it is priced will impact hundreds of thousands of people. This makes the need for fair practice even greater.

The fact that the Central Bank is clamping down on the issue is to be welcomed - the industry and regulators need to work together to ensure fair and equal treatment of all consumers.”

Discrepancy among men & women

The survey, conducted by iReach, also interestingly highlights that more men than women are likely to experience dual pricing with 66% of men saying they have experienced the practice, versus 51% of women.

However, 30% of women surveyed said they were completely unaware of the practice, signalling that women may actually be more at risk of overpaying for insurance products. 

More women than men also indicate that they don’t understand what dual pricing actually is - 29% versus 18% respectively.

Mr. Walsh continued:

The scourge of “dual pricing” has been around for too long.

Our hope is that continued action at government level will further the case for eliminating the practice of dual pricing and that sufficient steps will be taken in order to drive it out.

However, the hands of the consumer are not altogether tied either. As consumers, we can take steps to ensure we are getting the best value on the market – we simply need to shop around.

Results also showed that younger cohorts, or those between the ages of 18-24 (66%), are most likely to have experienced dual pricing in some form - understandable with less experience of insurance renewals and such!

Meanwhile, those in the 25-34 age bracket (29%) are most likely to say they weren’t aware of the practice.

Compare insurance prices on bonkers.ie

Think you might be overpaying on insurance? The good news is that comparing the insurance market is easy on bonkers.ie!

You can compare life insurance, serious illness insurance, mortgage protection insurance and home insurance quickly with our easy-to-use comparison tools.

Did you know that you can also compare prices and deals for energy, broadband and banking products on bonkers.ie? Discover how much you could save on your everyday expenses today!

If you’re looking for more insurance-related information, we have a range of blogs and guides that will help you navigate the insurance industry:

Make sure you check out our full range of insurance blogs and guides to learn more.

Get in touch with us

Are you surprised to learn that women are less aware of dual pricing than men? Have you experienced dual pricing or price walking? We’d love to hear from you!

Feel free to comment below or get in touch with us on Facebook, Instagram or Twitter.